Reviews for Saint☆Young Men

DO NOT READ THIS MANGA IF YOU ARE: a) Easily offended b) Studiously religious in either Christianity or Bhuddism c) Consider any humour about religion or religiousicons to be blasphemous d) An idiot who won't get the joke Moving on swiftly......WRONG, WRONG, WRONG, WRONG, WRONG. That's what this manga is. Very, very, wrong, but in such a deliciously divisive, amazingly anarchic, furiously funny, and exceptionally entertaining way.

Saint Young Men is a manga by Nakamura Hikaru that was serialised in Kodansha's Morning 2 manga magazine in 2007.

Okay, the basic concept is that after the turn of the millenium, Jesus and Buddha decide to take a break from the heavenly lifestyle (and ensuring the world didn't end), and return to earth for a while on an extended vacation. They end up sharing an apartment in Japan, and are slowly becoming familiar with the vibrant new world of the 21st century.

The story is basically slice of life, but with a very surreal, and very humourous difference. Don't expect this to be anything like YKK, Aqua or Aria. This is a devilishly different slice of life manga, and because of it's twisted take on such iconic figures, it may offend a number of people who read it. Thankfully, I'm not one of those people as I'm not easily offended and I like my humour to be a little more warped than normal.

The art style is very clean, and quite detailed. The backdrops, scenery, towns, etc, are all very detailed and well drawn. The character designs are very well done, although Buddha and Jesus are fairly limited design wise (Jesus wears a crown of thorns and Buddha's hair is like a statue's). Even with this though, Nakamura has managed to breathe life into the characters, making them by turns inquisitive, caring, joyful, terrified, etc, etc. The characters display awide variety of emotions that are easily readable without any text or sound effects - a testament to Nakamura's ability to draw exressions.

As far as character's go, one would think that Jesus and Buddhawould be fairly limited. Not so! They are comedy characters par excellence, and the two mesh extremely well as they spend their days just loitering around and generally hanging out. The side characters haven'tall been introduced yet though, so I can't comment on them, but the two main characters are strongenough to drive the story forward without the need for support.

This is a great series to read if you're bored or justlooking for something new and funny. It is to manga, what Gintama is to anime, and the manga pays homage to Gintama by lscattering references here and there. Osamu Tezuka's Buddha also gets mentioned, ironically enough.

It's rare for me to rave about a manga or anime, but this is one of the few occasions where I'll make my judgement based on 3 chapters. This is an exceptionally funny take on the slice of life genre, and even though it may offend some people, I would heartily recommend it to anyone.

If Jesus and Buddha were as cool in RL as they are in the mange, then we'd all be following them already :)

Actually, as someone who considers himself a Christian theist, I thoroughly enjoy[ed] this series. 'Suspension of belief' is required, but this is the way for most books/movies regardless. Do I find this manga offensive? Not in the slightest. Perhaps quite the contrary, this is a very enjoyable, and rather lightweight .. story [used loosely] about Jesus and Buddha sharing a apartment. Other than the obvious religious themed jokes [i.e Buddha winning a giant statue of Buddah at Disneyland, Jesus being afraid to swim (hence walking on water)], it manages to develop a interesting relationship between the two. It's religious deity buddy comedy manga at it's finest.

I'm not a religious person, but I had learned Buddhism and Christianity. I think I can really enjoy the gag because I can see from both point of view. This series use gag by secretly use "miracle" that comes from both religion that maybe unnoticed by another one, and in unpredictable way(like when the cat comes to them when Jesus unintentionally say that they're lack of food---taken from Jataka tales, but it should be rabbit though). I think this story flow naturally and ridiculously funny, but it can be offend some fanatic believer.

This story has lots of logical plot holes. Jesus and Buddha won't be friends because if they're accurate, Jesus won't like Buddha since it's another religion. After all, Christianity doesn't allow other religions like Buddhism to exist. And if they look like actual religious figures, everyone would realize who they are since it's the 21st century. Expecially when they had to haul the 1:1 Buddha statue home, people will notice that Buddha looks like Buddha. And since they technically don't have passports, driver's licenses, bank accounts, school records, or whatever, they couldn't actually rent an apartment. But they did, so it's unrealistic. Isn't it ruiningJesus's image from a Christian standpoint because it's trying to make a comedy of their almighty being? I'm not religious, but my parents are. Saint Young Men is a logical disaster. It ignores the core theological conflict between Christianity and Buddhism for the sake of forced friendship. Furthermore, it completely bypasses the reality of 21st-century civil infrastructure (IDs, bank accounts, apartment rental laws). It treats world-famous icons as invisible to the public, which is a statistical impossibility in the age of smartphones. A shallow comedy that relies on breaking its own world's rules.

This spoilerless review comes from someone who in most cases prefers anime and doesn't enjoy manga in general. I have watched the short anime of Saint Oniisan and few years later decided to give the manga a chance. This is the only manga that I really love and enjoy reading! I don't agree with opinions that this manga is not for religious people. I was raised as a Catholic and I am also interested in Buddhism and other religions. To me this manga almost belongs to spiritual literature. You can really appreciate and enjoy all the jokes in there when you are familiar with the biographiesof Buddha and Jesus. The author must have thoroughly studied sources from both religions, sometimes also referencing Shinto and other spiritual teachings. It is a great reading even for people who are unfamiliar with either of them since the personalities of the main characters are just what you would expect from saints. There are also notes explaining some puns at the end of each episode. This manga shows Jesus and Buddha as normal guys, enjoying their vacation (taking a break from Heaven) in Japan, being nice and kind and...well saint! Their holiness also brings them to unexpected funny situations.

I believe that if those two met in real life they would be such good pals as in this manga. This also shows the deeper level or spirituality which is the same in both Christianity and Buddhism. This story is a great message of peace, not looking for differences but for things that those two religions are having in common.

The jokes are not offensive in any way and they are funny as hell...I mean heaven! ^_^" The art is very nice and the author also shows other characters connected to the main ones such as their disciples, angels and other heavenly beings, etc. The manga is episodic with only slight connection between the stories. This manga is simply cute!

So, Jesus and Buddha move into an apartment together- ........ (You're still with me? Okay good. (*・ω・)ﾉ ) - After coming down from the heavens and to Tokyo for a vacation as tourists. That is the premise. That's it. Is it ridiculous: Yes. Is is potentially offensive: .....I dunno? I'm actually not religious so...┐(￣ヮ￣)┌ Is is surprisingly wholesome: Absolutely. Jesus is a bro, and befriends people of all types wherever he goes. Buddha can find ways to become enlightened in even the most comical of circumstances. Together they have the best chemistry and get up to all sorts of wacky shenanigans. Not onlythat, but the jokes are *really* clever. There's lot's referential religious humor that play into the history of Christianity and Buddhism, and actually none of what I've seen seems to be mean spirited. Honestly, I haven't read humor this clever and witty since Sayonara Zetsubou Sensei, (Although that's a matter of personal taste.) even though those two titles are opposing ends of the humor spectrum.

So far, great read, very wholesome and clever. Highly recommend.