Reviews for Wane Koi Tsumi

it's hard to rate it cause it was so... short and so... um... yaoi Story: 9 Original, cute, but there was something (i don't know what) that doesn't let me write a 10... Art: 10 God it was wonderful! Beautiful and stuff... If i hadn't known it was yaoi I'd be 100% fooled by the beauty of the character. Character: 9 Well even though they seemed to be so nice, manga managed to make it a bit shabby in the end... or not...Enjoyment: 10

Well... ahm... It was... good.

Overall: 9

Something was wrong in it... something... i wonder what...

Definitely not the best one of the mangaka. Unless you are fond of sheer porn, skip it. Story: 2 It could have been good if developed properly, but unfortunately, it is not. It takes about four pages to provide the reader with the circumstances of Eisuke and his pet, the rest is all about sex. Art: 7 For those who like Hoshino's art the art of this one will be as appealing as her other stories. Definitely not for those who don't like girly ukes. Character: 2 The characters are shallow and not interesting. What is even worse, Eisuke's attitude suddenly inexpicably changes 180 degrees at the end... Enjoyment: 1 I felt prettydisappointed when reading this manga. I've read other stories of the mangaka's and expected something much better.

Overall: 2

The story has some potential (although unfulfilled), and the art is pretty, but the rest isn't even worth mentioning.