Reviews for Prophecy
Back to MangaYokokuhan in short gives off the death note feels but on a more realistic scale. This story is about a boy who wants to help people punish society for all the bad its done to the people. Much like kira from death note are main character also go's by a nickname of Shinbunshi because of the newspaper bag he wears to hide his identity. He acts as a man of justice, but at first nothing was to serious but with the hype and media/internet things start to get out of control. I found this manga very good and a change of pace withgood mystery trying to find out more of are main character and his past also the suspense of how he will handle all the popularity and things going to a huge level with more and more crimes happening and if and how he will be caught by the law in the end.
This is a story that hits very close to home because all of us live in it; the era of the internet and everything that entails, such as flame wars, hiding behind anonymity, getting viral, getting defamed overnight, etc and how those things can affect society. It has some very accurate depictions of what most of you have encountered online at some point and this is what makes it interesting. The plot itself is simple enough; an almost classic police chase in a digital age. It is linear with our “villain”, Paperboy, notifying online and punishing mostly everyday people for their misdeeds which subsequently have causedpain to others and thus, slowly trying to gain support from the public. It comes down to brain battles between him and the leader of the team chasing him, Erika Yoshino, though none of them is direct; he is set on doing something and she is trying to solve the puzzles of his actions while figuring out how to stop his next attacks. There are no real plot twists, everything is revealed at a timely manner and that is how the story moves along.
It manages to keep the interest high, because our guy tells an aspect of society that many know but can do nothing about and it makes you wonder how right or wrong is either side. The pacing is pretty good as it is only 3 volumes long thankfully and is realistic enough at how things are done so it will not waste time on one thing forever just to drag on. Exposition-wise, it can be a bit dull as the first few chapters try to explain even the simplest of things through the form of a colleague who is forced to act as a pawn that knows nothing and always asks things. The ending albeit being fitting enough and semi-realistic, it was not the climax of the build-up I was waiting for. Something felt missing, rushed and not well done.
The characters do not have any development really, but that does not mean they are bad. They are set to act their roles in a specific story and that is what they do. We do have backstories and reasons for the things we get to know, so there is some character background, but that is it. They could have had more moments to themselves for us to see more of their human side instead of just seeing their actions. However, most of the characters are relatable and their actions make sense, which is really the most important thing for a story. On the side, we do get to see some of the behaviors of people online, which are really realistic…
Art-wise, it was very detailed and with a clean design that depicts everything as is. The character designs are unique giving a mature and realistic look to them, while the expressions are well made. It also features a lot of online instances such as Nico Nico comments on a video or 2chan, etc. which was a happy surprise to see sometimes and made it feel even more current. Was it memorable? Not really, but it did fit the whole story and was very pleasing to the eye.
All in all, I was satisfied with what I read. It was not the best story and it did not have the best characters, but I appreciated it that it used a current theme and kept the realism going for the most part, while providing enough interest. Towards the ending, with the reveal of the finer details, it can feel a bit forced, but it does not ruin the whole experience. I would definitely recommend it for a quick read.
Prophecy is not about one thing exactly, as it touches many topics, but this manga does it all with mastery. Some of the topics are: 1)Cancel culture and topics related to internet authoritarism (even extending that to physical violence) are constantly dealed withing the whole manga 2)The corruption lying inside the heroes that people love (even leaders of political manifestations) 3)Authoritarism of the police 4)corruption in the politics 5)And even how extreme we tend to be when we are using social media 6)How capitalism pushes people to do absurd work only to survive, and the violence neoliberalism propagates just by its existence etc. The characters are all very good, the police andthe terrorists, all very well written and it's really easy to get yourself laughing and cheering with them whitin all the chapters.
The dialogues are great, they aren't that kind of dialogue that you want to skip, they are intrinsic to the book and cannot be separated from it, like some kind of filler.
The art is pretty good too, when it needs to be more explicit it is, and when it needs to be funny it does it well too.
After all, it's a manga that will make you stop trusting people blindly, after all, it's a book that makes you think on yourself, don't depending to the vision of any authoritarism, even the authoritarism of the freedom thinkers of the internet.
"Reading is equivalent to thinking with someone else's head instead of with one's own." - Schopenhauer.
Note: I hate quantifying a manga scoring in multiple categories - story/characters/pacing etc - because to me that's just min-max type of scrutiny that dilutes the holism of the entire work. So, I'm going to score the entire manga as a whole and nothing else and tell you why I liked the manga. This is a short and sweet manga. It's not phenomenal in any regard but one - the walls do feel like they're closing fast. And that feeling makes it a really nice manga. It's sweet, short, and does what it sets out to do best - portray the "mob mentality" of internet in thebackground and a sweet story of friendship in the background all tied with a bow of cat-mouse police chase.
It begins by putting forward a lot of questions and I'm so happy that all of them get answered in due time. It's short, the manga, but it's not rushed at all. It's adequately paced and very nice.
All characters other than the police are great. The police characters are so lame lol, but then again, doesn't matter because you're not rooting for the police at all. Still, they're so lame its funny.
The art is nice, and grim. I like it.
Read it. 7/10.
This is a very solid work, especially for being such a short read. The only strong critique I have are how the general political and societal themes are presented and discussed. Often certain elements feel caricaturized and lacking depth, without making strong enough or decisive statements for me to really understand how the author feels or what they want the takeaway to be. Normally that isn't too much of an issue, but the author does spend enough time working around these topics that it feels like I should have a stronger opinion. While the characters are generally interesting the real star of the show isthe underlying plot. The twists and turns following motive, identity, and execution can genuinely be a thrill at best and only kind of predictable at worst. It is best experienced blind so I shall not say much here. The only other minor critique is that I wish the ending was a little stronger, even if it was just one more chapter of resolution - but I did really love that final scene. Overall, this one is worth checking out if you are in search of a fun thriller, and especially if you (like me) enjoy following a genius protagonist in a battle of wits.