NeonIME LogoNeonIME

Reviews for Goshimei desu!

Back to Manga
y
yumi15kl

over 16 years ago

9

anyone that reads a oneshot knows how rare a good one is. when i say this, i dont mean the one shots that are spin off of some other manga, I mean the real ones. in my eyes this one was awesome . the problem about most one shots is that they seem rushed and and there is little to no character delvopment. with they you get 2 strong leads and good supporting cast. this story had a really good flow and and easy to follow story.

12
Preliminary
Recommended
Preliminary
A
Amiable_Raven

about 16 years ago

7

This is a nice little short, if you are just looking for a really quick read. There isn't any huge development in character or story, even though this one-shot has the potential to be a great story. Which is disappointing that Mayu didn't take it any father. The ending is predictable and with the little bit of character depth you do learn makes the ending that much MORE obvious. It is a cute short work. But the story can't even live up to the the amazing artwork that is Mayu's. If you are looking for something to pass the a little time then this would dothe job. If this we longer or had a squeal that builds on it, that would be the only way I would strongly suggest reading that. But since that isn't the case I would say that it's not worth it, which is really disappointing.

4
Preliminary
Recommended
Preliminary