NeonIME LogoNeonIME

Reviews for A crazy elf and a serious orc.

Back to Manga
T
TheHentaiKing

over 7 years ago

4

*Disclaimer* Just personal scratch. Advised, possible spoilers. Opinion & Informal Art: 5/10 Basic. I wouldn't say elementary, but I wouldn't be surprised at all if some kid drew all the art. Anatomy was believable. Proportions were alright. Semi-cute-realistic style. Plot: 4/10 Stupid. Pretty attractive elf comes up with some convoluted and baseless reasoning that she wants to get violated by a well-to-do orc. Leave the dude alone, crap she was annoying. Development: 4/10 Pointless. Any of the actual developments to add a bit of meat to this story was just so forced and half-assed. This whole manga should have been done as a one-shot. It pretty much added somehalf-assed extra development to the plot to add maybe 3 chapters of filler.

Characters: 4/10 Bland. Elf nothing more than a pretty face. Orc, same thing. The orc was just a receptacle to the lewdness and honestly just felt like a mode of self-insert.

Conclusion: 4/10 Stupid, stupid aftermath. Open-ended ending with a half-assed resolution for the future.

Panel Progression: 5/10 Average. Nothing was too confusing. Failed as an ecchi manga because there weren't any use of service shots or impact-panels highlighting "anything."

Overall: 4/10 Boring. Somewhat titillating at times.

5
Not Recommended
M
Makey

almost 7 years ago

3

I only came across this because I had previously saw 'II ORC NO HI' which already has this theme, it isn't a proper manga like this but I personally found that one to be more amusing, the less polished art style and the shorter it was. Having enjoyed 'II ORC NO HI' and looking at this, I can't help but make comparisons, the concept of the idea is amusing but I found it worked better in 'II ORC NO HI' because of how short the jokes and scenes were but in 'Hentai Elf to Majime Orc' it's much longer and more detailed (visually), in the firstplace there really isn't much to stand on it's own which is why I feel so much effort being put into this feels like a waste as the whole 'orc rape' thing is used as a joke, it can only go so far and it's best used as a quick joke.

2
Preliminary
Not Recommended
Preliminary
Y
Yungboi

over 5 years ago

3

The "plot" is wholesome. Kinda reminds me of Belle Delphine's premium snapchat... Might be appealing to horny middle school teens that hit puberty or to some type of oldass 50 year old dude who has 0 slick talk game. I personally didn't like it too much, it took some serious subjects wayy to lightly including rape. So if you feel soft about stuff like that then don't read it. If you are into kinky sh** though then go ahead and plow right through 15 chapters of trolling. "Plot": 9.9 The rest: -0 ( -0 should be a number tbh) ... it says my review has to be longer...how was your day?

cool cool. Yeah i like breathing too... oh for real? That's crazy!!! Nyeah ok.

0
Not Recommended