NeonIME LogoNeonIME

Reviews for Phantom of the Idol

Back to Anime
K
KANLen09

over 3 years ago

7

Idoly Pride X Budoukan, Uramichi Oniisan edition. Never thought that the mish-mesh of those formulas would work so well. Idol shows. You might've heard them aplenty, much less seen them in action, even if it's clips on YouTube showcasing how much of a juggernaut genre this is in Japan, and there is absolutely no shortage of them since it's a cultural phenomenon over in the Land of the Rising Sun. But, amongst the many copy-and-paste plans that have little to divide and stand out, how mangaka Hijiki Isoflavone managed to shine through with a story that sounds so typical, yet looks so paradox, is certainly baffling.And in the midst of a small following to the lot of you that watched this show, can most certainly say that you've enjoyed this in some capacity, this is my huge surprise in the lacklustre Summer 2022 season to say that I really enjoyed this. A LOT. And I'm not kidding.

Usually, idol stories are just basically a bread-and-spread affair of repeating the tropes that the somewhat idol genre has been maligned for but not talked about a while lot, but in a very simple way, Hijiki Isoflavone incorporated 2 things: adulting, and the paranormal. And the adulting ranges from this boy pop duo ZINGS, which comprises of the youthful Kazuki Yoshino and the adult lazy-straightlaced Yuuya Niyodo. While Yoshino has a lot going for him with his looks and childlike voice that would be enough to earn big amounts of fans, Niyodo is the complete opposite with his darker, bass-like voice that just screams total laziness and uncharacteristic for the idol industry: a sloppy, half-assed personality and hostile behaviour towards his fans, that he is the plague of the duo whom just wanted enough to quit being an idol. The unique plot twist, is that Niyodo encounters another idol: the beloved and popular singer, 17-year-old Asahi Mogami, whose life was tragically cut short due to an accident, robbing her of her prime days of idoling. Having been dead for a year, she desperately wants to get back into the industry, but she has nowhere else to turn to being a ghost...and that's where Niyodo enters the scene with a clear win-win situation on Asahi possessing Niyodo, showcasing his vibrant side that definitely is a total 180 to shock fans with ease. This is the journey of Niyodo and Asahi as they venture through the lifeblood of the newbie, but fledgling ZINGS as the joining of forces between yesterday's real star and today's dirtbag, initiates the Phantom of the Idol's story and their rise to decent fame.

On hindsight, a ghost and a living human for a comedy seems like a recipe for disaster, but how Hijiki Isoflavone weaved this intricate comedy can only best be described as a niche of sorts, very similar to Uramichi Oniisan. The story itself has some funny elements between Niyodo and Asahi, and each of them already had their charm from the get-go, that with the ghost possessing collaboration of an idol who's pretty much done with his job and the idol whom died but still wants to continue her legacy even after death, brings about the comedic tones that's just oh-so-perfect. Even more so with Yoshino being tagged along as the other half of ZINGS, try as hard as he might to convince the lazy, Uramichi Oniisan-influenced Niyodo to perform at his best, it depends on his mood to get over and deal with it, and that's already saying about his childlike voice that pleases the ears of the many.

But don't go for a sec thinking that ZINGS are the only people that make up this show, because what makes it more engaging and entertaining are the side casts that amp up the insane comedy strikes that at times, can be a hit or miss. Manager Hitomi Shinano is the one that glues the duo together; the Niyodo (Hardcore, Happy Three Friends) Fan Club of Kasenjiki, Tsugiko and Shigutaro is a wild goose chase of having their post-night bar activities and analyzing each and every of Niyodo's actions and fantasizing to the insane degree. God I love the trio's unkempt dedication and endless praise to the dirtbag. And last but not least, where there's the main idol group, there'll be veteran groups, such as the case of the boy idol band Cgrass and its strange leader Hikaru Setouchi, whom has been the hardcore fan of Asahi's enough to sense the Phantom in Niyodo and clash the psychological battle of not being found out. Every character does at least make sense, from Niyodo's Uramichi Oniisan to Asahi's Idoly Pride, and the Niyodo Fan Club's Budoukan vibes giving the show its run for the comedy, which is definitely not for everyone, that it takes a certain level of people like you and me to enjoy the simplicity of a story that has the comedy driven in its own length of hilarity.

I do feel that the need for CG in idol shows have since become the overrated usage, and this perception will not change for future idol shows going forward. Sadly, what Studio Gokumi has done here is only a touch above the average mean with somewhat mediocre but "acceptable" CGI for the dances, which to be honest, I would be happy if it didn't came with it just to save a measure of the insanely expensive anime production cost. Elsewhere, everything here just seems like an ordinary low-tier show that has been given a relatively small budget to work with since the anime didn't really set on fire for being just your oh-so-typical idol show with a unique twist, that come what may, will not change the perception of the majority out there. It's just alright and serviceable for a standard such as this.

But where Kami Kuzu☆Idol really shines is in its songs, which is for the par of course, its own set of songs that have been curated for this sole purpose. Both Fumiya Imai and Shun Horie did a knockout job on their part as the main duo ZINGS of Niyodo and Yoshino respectively, given that the former is best well-known for Given's supporting boy Hiiragi Kashima and the latter, one of my favourite characters in a while: Dragon, Ie wo Kau.'s scaredy-cat dragon Letty (and KanoKari's simp Kazuya unfortunately). Even Nao Touyama as Asahi Mogami has had her share of fun being the ghost idol and also with one of her ED songs. Speaking of the OST, ZINGS's OP, holy wowsers is it very catchy and fun to listen to, and I'd be glad to put this amazing song on repeat for days on end, definitely one of my top OPs of the season. The many scores of ED songs range from decent to good, and I'm fine with all of them either way for a different mesh that serves up "bang"s (though not to the point of banger).

All in all, I still thought that Kami Kuzu☆Idol a.k.a Phantom of the Idol would've been an underappreciated show, given the many tropes and its kinda lackluster freestyle way of storytelling. But this is part of the charm why this show works, and I for one, as mentioned in the beginning, embraced it and came out with a smile on my face. Maybe not the show that I would remember a season or 2 after it finishes, but all I can say is: thank you Kami Kuzu☆Idol for lighting up my sweltering Summer 2022 seasonal run, that despite the short 10-episode runtime, I didn't feel like I've wasted my time watching a show that's for the very niche. And even if you come out with a different feeling that this show isn't so much worth your time, if you just wanna chill out to idols and ghost possessions, the wacky comedy style, it'll do.

Let's ZING! ZING for Smile!

16
Recommended
E
Ellenwitch

over 3 years ago

7

A lot needs to go into a show, for things to click, and to work. Which is what this show does and more so. It's engaging, it can be amusing, and most of all.It's likable in it's own way, but with it's own twist, that'll stand out more and more. It honestly reminds me of a mix of Budoukan x Idoly Pride x it's own charm. Which can only be a good thing. Story and characters: 7 Being an idol is a serious thing. You can't just waltz into it, thinking you're going to make a easy buck. But it's where our story leads us, Niyodo, prettymuch one of the most lazy and unenthusiastic idols you will ever meet, about to be fired, now has a once in a life time cheat code to his name...The power of a dead famous idol in Mogami Asahi, able to take over him, and be her usual idol self. Niyodo, seeing this as a perfect opportunity, pushes a win-win as he calls it, situation. To let her enjoy being an idol again, while he can relax and make an easy stretch about it. But with how this story has gone, you can maybe guess. Things may change. Which if developed nicely, will only stand out more and more.

It's that kind of story that makes it fun and creative. But with how both of the characters naturally vibe off of each other. Yet alone the other cast members to boot. It makes for a show worth watching. It isn't painful on the ears by any stretch. Nor are the characters eye rolling. It's enjoyable from the get go. Sure, it has it's flaws. But it makes t up with it's charm, and personality. When it comes it's character interactions, and out right good cast line, that'll drag the show forward.

Art and sound: 7

The style is clean, pretty, engaging. Even with the usual 3D styled idol dance moves, it still looks nice in general. But also once again, when it comes to idol animes, the music is great. I actually really enjoyed the first song that they sang, and I'm sure you will too. The reactions from the cast too,how it's animated, it's good. Top notch there. Plus if you want a main highlight of why this is so creatively fun and charming.Just see episode three, and it's ending, and you'll get a good glimpse of that.

Kami Kuzu is surpisingly charming and amusing for sure. A good watch if you're looking for something to just vibe with. Keep watching for sure, as I'm sure, the story will ramp up even furter, which can only be a good ting.

16
Preliminary
Recommended
Preliminary
S
Stormy_77

over 3 years ago

7

Went into this expecting an anime type treatment of Idol anime mash-up with Phantom of the Opera and was pleasantly surprised to find there was something new and different in this story with a lot of heart. Animation - Sub Par - 5/10 Let's get the bad news out of the way first. The CGI 2D/3D animation is a little wonky and not great. The high water mark of 2D rotoscope or motion capture would be Yuri on Ice, and possibly Dance Dance Danseur. This anime is maybe 30% of that. It's visible and obviously not the best. The only good thing I can say is theyat least got the dancing right, plus it's ULTRA obvious the Yoshino dancer guy is a much better dancer than Niyodo, he's got all the right flourishes at the right places to give that extra Oomph to a dance performance. Kudos to him! So the animation is a problem but the character designs are great. Asahi (the ghost) is personable and cute, Yoshino is adorable and Niyodo is the tall, handsome one. In short, good character designs, rotoscope but animation could have been handled better at least to Idolish 7 standard.

Music / OST - Slightly above Mid - 6/10

Music wise all the songs are nice and catchy, but not necessarily memorable. I'd dance to them if they came on though.

Story and Characters - 8/10.

The story and characters are where this anime breaks new ground. Character wise, we have Niyodo who became an idol because he was lazy and wanted a way to make a quick buck. He makes no bones about being what he is but that's not the normal mold of idols, which Asahi and Yoshino fit. They try their best to get him to at least like his career, which is what good friends do because his initial wave slave mentality was honestly off-putting at the start. Still, it's refreshing to actually see an introvert succeed as an idol with support from his partner, management and fans.

Where this anime shines is in its examination of fans, FANDOM and all that entails, good AND bad. Obsessive fans. Stalkers. Haters. Devoted ones with high expectations. Idols having zero break or privacy as everything these days is instant news. Where does one draw the line between work and private time? What is the true cost of success if an idol has to have a "fake persona" to please fans 24/7? These and other themes are explored in a non judgmental, light-hearted manner that still gives the viewer plenty of food for thought.

And of course, the shining stars and best part of this anime were the "nerd" fans. They were LIFE!! The nerd fans provided so much comedy I wanted another season just so I can vicariously "squeee" and be FANS with them. The Calendar episode had me in stitches. It's hard not to identify with some aspect of those fans as there are some bands I was 100% fan-girling at so I really identified with them and they're the real reason I enjoyed this anime so much.

Recommended if you like Idol and Music Anime, with a message that is subtle but wholesome.

8
Recommended
N
Neo_Randomz

over 3 years ago

8

An idol and a ghost,quite an interesting combination,last time Idoly Pride use the same concept and now we got Kami Kuzu Idol as the successor. Is it enjoyable ? yes is it as good as idoly pride ? NOPE,not even close The anime actually doesn't start really good with me,the reason is one of the MC is basically one of the anime tropes that I hated the most,The "Im too lazy and busy for this sh*t",I almost dropped this show in an instant BUT I keep watching and watching even though I already bored,until Asahi comes and gives me an instant smile,I always love a cheerful anime girland Asahi definitely one of em,my wills to keep watching suddenly increased.Even after I learned that Asahi is a ghost of a dead idol and I know that ghost and human relationship usually ends badly (unless it's Yuragi-sou no Yuuna-san ofc),I keep on watching it,though there's some more major let down like the personality change that to be honest very...*cringe*(sorry),i keep on watching it and actually kinda like it and thought to myself "oh this ain't so bad,not dropping it is definitely a good decision".

Atleast,UNTIL THEY START DANCING

CAUSE JESUS CHRIST WHAT THE FCK IS THAT...?

The CGI-ish animation of that dance is just terrible,some of you might say "I've seen worse" or "you have a too high standard" well let me tell you,the bad CGI that we watch usually came from an action anime where it doesn't really matter to me like that turtle scene from Shield hero or the dragon CGI from Kenja no Deshi,cause in the end,all those CGI is just a mere passing through scene that can forgotten after a few minutes,but here we watch an idol anime where movement and choreography is a one of the point of interest from an idol anime and it pretty much mean that we will see atleast once every episode,now imagine watching that turtle and dragon CGI scene but longer and worse,you have to watch it in EVERY SINGLE EPISODE.

The way their eyes looks,their movement that looks like the total opposite of fluid.Compared to idoly pride,the dance scene is straight up garbage.

They looks like a prototype version of husbando AI that trynna copy some move from youtube KPOP dance tutorial or better,they looks like people with kyphosis trying to pull some cool dance moves in a night club.

Some people maybe dislike my takes on the dance scene,but you do you,i can't stand that.

I rather close my eyes and only listen to the music( which is actually pretty good)

everytime that dance scene pop out.

To be honest,the only reason that keep me watching and give this show an 8 is Asahi and the music.

So overall,not recommended.

If you want to watch the story with similar concept and don't mind about a bleaker story,i suggest you to watch Idoly Pride.

But if you still insist to watch this out of curiousness,go ahead,nobody stopping you cause in the end,i will finished this kyphosis dance club anime as well

8
Preliminary
Recommended
Preliminary
b
bossunhimeswitch

over 3 years ago

7

I wasn't sure what to make of the PV, but I decided to give this anime a chance anyway and I'm really glad that I did. The characters were fun and engaging, the comedy made me laugh, and there were come cute and heartfelt moments scattered throughout the episodes. It was fun to watch how possession changed not only Nyodo but also Asahi as well. The recurring secondary characters were also a treat from the sweet and sincere Yoshino to the enthusiastic fan club members to the rival idols. There were no characters I dreaded seeing on screen. If you're looking for an anime towatch casually, this is a good pick. Just kind of go with the flow of it and it'll be worth it especially as the story progresses past the first few episodes.

4
Recommended
J
Jozuwa-_-

over 3 years ago

7

3 episodes in and I'm still having fun! This is the execution I expected from "Uramichii-Oniisan", concept-wise, but was never delivered. So I appreciate this Anime doing its concept justice. Story I like that even when there are only 10 episodes for this Anime (7 more to go) they're not rushing the character development of the protag. He's managing to show some caring, but it's still driven mainly by his selfish reasonings. I mean... who the heck manipulates a spirit's feelings mid-rapture so they can remain in this world to do his work XD CHARACTERS: As mentioned above, the protag, Yuuya, remains a selfish lazy middle-aged man which makes thecharacter easy to play around with. Coupled with the persuasive ghost, Asahi, who's now starting to control Yuuya on impulse, trouble just comes around so quickly... which is great cause it's fun for us viewers :P

Yoshino is mostly the damsel-in-distress of the story so far.

The president provides the "SHOCK DESU!!!" reaction for whatever antics the Trash/Idol duo pulls. She's also the resident banter character for Yuuya but, not enough banter bits from them so far, so that's not saying much.

The 3 Yuuya fanatics' mini-role have been utilized so well. They only get a few minutes, if not seconds of screentime (plus one after-credits scene) but they've been quite fun so far.

ART & SOUND:

The animation quality is definitely low. BUT, I think it's sufficient enough for this kind of Anime. (I can't imagine myself being able to focus on the story and comedy if Asahi was Animated better... just saying :P )

VAs for the 2 protags and the 3 fans has been good so far. I even feel like it's a big reason both the Yuuya and Asahi character works well. Not that big of a fan of Yoshino's and the possessed Yuuya's voices though. Noth that it's bad, it just doesn't add anything to the characters.

I'm not into the style of the OP & ED but, I think those are pretty fitting themes for this Anime.

OVERALL:

This has been a "zero expectation" viewing for me so far. I watch it without expecting anything from the story progression, character development, or even the comedy. I just play it and get a fun episode every time... so far, that is. Hope it keeps being fun till the end.

3
Spoiler
Preliminary
Recommended
Preliminary
Spoiler
P
PixelB

about 3 years ago

7

I do not like idol anime. However, I am compelled to always pick one up with a slightly interesting premise. But hell, this isn't even my first idol show that I watched with a ghost assisting the MC, which was Idoly Pride, and that one was a disaster. So I wasn't really looking forward to Kami Kuzu. Yet, contrary to my low expectations, the complaints that I usually have with idol anime are solved here. First off are the members of the idol group. Thank god that there's only two people in the idol group in this show. Usually, there's like 8+ members in an idolgroup, and all the members blend together. Of course, in a 12 episode run that needs to cram in story, there's no way that a large cast of members in an idol group are not going ot be heavily archetyped. With a small two member cast in Kami Kuzu, there's a lot more opportunity for individuality and for you to get to know the two members well.

Niyodo obviously has a lot of screen time because he's the MC, so you get to know him a lot. He's lazy, gets tired, has no particular hobbies, and enjoys getting money for free. His manzai with both Yoshino, and Asahi are nice. The gimmick in this show is that the lazy Niyodo can always trade places with an energetic Asahi to create a inconsistent idol personality, where some of his performances are energetic, and the others, more lethargic. That brings me to the to Asahi. While she's just a super generic idol personality that I'd hate if she were just the MC of another show, her setting being that she's a ghost that's haunting Niyodo makes her a much more bearable and endearing character. Again, both Niyodo and Asahi would be a bit too boring by themselves, but the pairing with each other completes them to become a good duo. Finally, we have Yoshino. If he was just in another generic idol group anime, he'd probably have little to no depth. However, him being the sole other member of Zings makes him a lot better of a character. He's a good friend to Niyodo, picking up the slack that he creates, while also trying his very best to overcome his own obstacles. He's lacks confidence, afraid of standing out and has stage freight, so he too, enjoys the company of a more confident Niyodo.

Did you see that? I just listed every relevant main character. There was only three! That's a shockingly small amount for an idol show, and that small character cast brings out the best of all three of them. The side characters are also great. The manager is good, but the otaku fans are honestly just as good as the main cast. There's a lot of focus on a specific die-hard fan group of ZINGS, and their perspectives contrasted to Niyodo's and Yoshino's are great. Just the conversations that they have and the excitement they get from the events make them an essential part of the show. there was only one scene where I thought they were a bit too over the top, but that's also because I believe the show dragged on a chapter's worth of content into an entire episode.

Other than that, there's also the poor animation. You can clearly tell that the anime reuses a lot of frames, and the conversations that the female fans are very static. The dance choreography honestly isn't the worst CGI, but it's also still unwatchable because of the horrific CGI. The facial expressions and mouth movement during dialogue aren't as dynamic as they should be. The last episode was basically a just concert with songs that ZINGS already sang, so they just reused all of the animation.

Overall, a low budget anime with some poor pacing in terms of reusing animation and dragging on episodes to save on animation, but the content and characters are actually far better than most idol shows.

2
Recommended
g
grr_mal

about 3 years ago

5

A very interesting premise that got my hopes up in the first few episodes, but unfortunately it's not developed and leads to nothing as you watch more. Explains why there were just 10 episodes - even that was probably hard to squeeze out of a "story" with no story. Even when we get moments with hints of possible development, like the risk of the ghost girl being recognized by a die-hard fan of hers, the authors chose to not shake things up. Disappointing. Well, I guess most people aren't in it so much for the story but for the music. Those will be happy with thefinal concert episode. It's a very subjective thing so check out if you like this kind of music from the trailers or something. Personally, I didn't like most of the songs, nor the CGI dancing that felt like repeating the same moves over and over every 5 seconds for almost 20 minutes straight. There was one song that had a part I liked in the middle and that's about it. I've not found a good music anime since Nana years ago, so I've mostly given up nowadays.

1
Not Recommended
C
Cutepid

over 3 years ago

10

Ghost x Idols what an interesting combination! Kami Kuzu☆Idol showcase Kazuki Yoshino and Yuuya Niyodo making the idol group zings. Yoshino works hard an succeeds every concert while Niyodo he's just using the "idols title" (despite his good looks) just a money making method. One day he meets this ghost named Mogami who died a year or so ago. Mogami's dream was to become and idol once again but only to find out she is able to watch other Idols for beside, while talking to Niyodo she went throught into his body, then Niyodo decide he is willing to help her find her dreams againbut instead with his body, with that she and him can both accomplish their goals, with her dreams and with his soon to be a bank.

I highly recommend this series to those who are into idols anime like Idolish7, Lovelive, BangDreams, 22/7, etc.

The anime is still currently airing so I might come back and give my final thoughts on Kami Kuzu☆Idol.

1
Spoiler
Preliminary
Mixed Feelings
Preliminary
Spoiler
M
MoshiMoshiOn

about 3 years ago

7

Un anime simple, carismático y entretenido... (no apto para quienes busquen romance, aviso antes de que se desilusionen) Comedia naif, con humor básico y constante. La historia es bastante simple y la trama avanza rápido, sin vueltas, así que no aburre pero tampoco sorprende mucho. Tiene sus momentos tristes y dramáticos obviamente, pues la protagonista es una idol muerta, pero pasan bastante rápido y se centra mas en la comedia. Los personajes no son tantos, todos son simpáticos (a su modo) y tienen el desarrollo necesario para empatizar con ellos, no mas, no se van por las ramas. Destaca Niyodo (el idol de pelo marrón), que tiene bastante mas pesocomo protagonista que el resto, ya que el humor del programa se centra casi por completo en su actitud despreocupada y desinteresada de todo lo que no sea dinero fácil. Me gusto que, si bien evoluciona a lo largo de la historia, por los diferentes sucesos, mantienen una coherencia que me resulto inesperada.

La fantasma, el rubio y la manager, cumplen con su parte, pero no destacan tanto.

Las fans son, sin duda, uno de los pilares de la comedia y se roban mas de una vez el protagonismo, me encontré varias veces viendo una escena con expectativa por como iban a reaccionar ellas y riéndome de antemano.

Ilustración decente, sin mucho detalle. Por ahí pifian, pero nada tan grave.

Musicalización y sonido bien en general; y los temas de la banda tampoco fueron tan malos, no me voy a hacer fan de Zings, pero algunos se me pegaron un toque.

Animación estándar, me gustó y el CGI no fue tan asqueroso, lo que es común en animes de idols.

Escribe @ES_CAY

1
Recommended
G
GT3_gamer

about 2 years ago

6

The premise is good, but the execution not so much. As a possession enjoyer, I'm hooked on the premise but left feeling just as I was when I was getting to this anime. Tho, I enjoy every fan interaction in this series. Yes, those are some of the best ones, in any anime. It's the charm of this anime. Not the MC but the SC that fangirling over their oshi. Oh and also kudos to the one who has the idea to make every episode have a unique outro. It had charm to it and I'm actually enjoy listening to all of the song. Overall - 5.9

0
Mixed Feelings
S
ScalchopWarrior

almost 3 years ago

6

In terms of general pitches I’ve received, “deadbeat idol strikes up a partnership with a ghost idol who helps him awaken his love of his work”, is certainly not the most expected story, though I suppose neither is it the oddest. Either way, it was enough to thoroughly grasp my attention on sheer randomness and absurdity alone. Is that really enough to claim any legitimate quality though? Well… [Writing] To begin, the general concept of Kami Kuzu Idol is certainly out-there and pretty original all things considered; and it doesn’t attempt to be too much more than what it sets out to, that being a light-hearted, comedic,slice of life-ish romp with fun gags and characters. The characters are definitely a stand-out, with distinct and fun personalities backed by wonderful performances from the VAs that got plenty of laughs out of me. Add that to some truly enjoyable gags and I was consistently enjoying my time with the show. I don’t consider it anything exceptional, but it’s serviceable as a means for the comedy, and that’s really enough to be entertaining.

[Grade - B+]

[Presentation]

In terms of its visuals, Kami Kuzu Idol really doesn’t have much of note; its animation is certainly passable enough on average, but nothing too impressive or distinct of an animation style or aesthetic that makes it stand out from an average anime. For better or worse, the most distinct animation definitely comes in the performances, where traditional animation is forgone in favor of using CGI models that look…passable, to say the least. However, the music is quite nice, particularly the performance songs, which makes said events more enjoyable than the visuals alone would otherwise make them.

[Grade - B]

[Fun value]

The anime is definitely a very fun time overall, and as a comedic series, much of its mileage certainly does depend on if the general vibe of the show is a hit or miss with you. Myself, I found it a fun and absurd show that constantly entertained, while offering the occasional hit of seriousness to balance the experience out. Therefore, I feel this aspect is definitely its strongest.

[Grade - A-]

In all, Kami Kuzu Idol is an entirely absurd story, but sufficiently tells its story for the intended purposes of comedy and character interactions. With some enjoyable characters, great VA performances, and fun gags, it’s a good time to watch, even if the visuals sometimes leave much to be desired. If you expect something deep or meaningful, while it has some interesting themes of enjoyment from work and the idol industry, you’ll likely still end up disappointed, but if one comes in expecting the light-hearted, fun romp that it is, then there’s some good times to be had.

[Grade - B+]

0
Mixed Feelings
i
i-like-this

over 3 years ago

7

Anime-drew Lloyd Webber. If you’re into your idol comedies then you’ll probably get a chuckle or two out of “Phantom of the Idol”. Pessimistic and apathetic towards being an idol, Niyodo is on the cusp of being fired from the idol duo ZINGS if he doesn’t get his act together. Whilst moping over how he’ll get his next paycheque he happens upon Asahi, a busty, bubbly, adorable… and dead ghost of a former idol who’s only attachment to the living world is a desperate need to sing on stage as an idol once more. Luckily for her Niyodo doesn’t enjoy the hard work that comes withbeing an idol so he strikes a deal with her so she can possess his body and do all of his idol performances for him.

“Phantom of the Idol” is what you get when you mix any happy-go idol anime together with “Uramichi Oniisan”. The standard moé blob comedy against cynical corporate pessimism is a formula for comedy that works surprisingly well and makes this anime quite unique in the idol genre. Niyodo’s exasperating sloth-ness and straightforwardness is not only a cause for the casts woes, but also a strange antidote in the fake, competitive idol world that cuts through and helps others like his indecisive duo partner Yoshino or his uptight competitor Setouchi. He’s so apathetic towards his work that he’s earns a strange following of fan-girls who’s devotion to him and after show commentary on him whilst having drinks is hilarious, but the personality “gap” that comes from Asahi performing after taking over his body and the reaction to that by his fans is probably one of my favourite comedy gags ever.

It’s animation is about what you’d expect from an idol show. The CGI mo-cap performances look fine but feel a bit janky to watch and the hand drawn animation nothing extraordinary. However they do manage to pack a lot of personality into the characters like Asahi, Niyodo, his duo partner Yoshino and their delightfully insane fanbase to make up for it. I get the feeling they had a lot of fun animating Asahi and giving her character a lot of life… ironically.

The humour does have a tendency to go a bit overboard and it sometimes gets a bit repetitive, but the anime overall is solid. I’ve really enjoyed watching “Phantom of the Idol” and if you’re someone who like idol comedies then I would recommend it.

7/10 Good.

0
Recommended
M
Mr_Socialite

almost 2 years ago

5

Like, it wasn't bad or anything. The show was super cute and all, but at the same time, it flew under the radar for me. I think a little of it may be a result of the story, and maybe this is also an issue with the development of the anime, but some things were so heavily focused, whereas other aspects that could have used more time did not receive the attention they needed. After episode 4, I wondered if I wanted to continue watching. I am never one to give up on an anime, so I went in to see if there was somethingI was missing, but there wasn't and I watched 10 episodes of a sub-par anime where I can't remember anything that happened besides idol fans being idol fans. The show ended like there may be room for a season two, but at the same time, it ended abruptly. I don't know.... if you want an anime to watch while doing dishes or household chores, I would say that this is a good one to do.

0
Mixed Feelings
x
xSunspot

almost 2 years ago

6

It started out good, by episode 4 I was already tired out. What the heck happened? I mean, the two main characters were somewhat interesting, so was the concept and the girl idol, so what went wrong? Focusing on non-interesting stuff, while there was a lot of work to be made to the plot. The four annoying nerdy fans looked more as the main characters, every episode focused on them, why should we care? All they did was sit at the bar, drink, and fangirling for very unnecessary stuff. It worked on some other animes, but on this one, eh, the less would have been better, itcompletely killed off my excitment and my will to care. This is my biggest problem with Kami Kuzu, but there is a lot more, as I said before, the plot needed more work. Episode 12 was rushed, they could have dig into the idol's past, but nah, of course we got the clichèd-singy episode, and the "pLeAsE c0nTinUe tO sUpPoRt uS!", wow, never heard that line in any anime before.

It could have given the Oshi No Ko vibes, and it somehow did on the first episode, but then.. yikes, not worth it.

0
Spoiler
Mixed Feelings
Spoiler
G
GensoTV

over 3 years ago

3

Big potential, but lame story without variety. I didn't expect much and I'm not into male Idols, maybe this is a reason for my rating and it would be higher with cute girls, but I guess not. It had potential at the beginning, but the story didn't have a progress nor development. I had hope for the finale, but no. The dances are 3D animated and not good. You suffer with Asahi, but she won't get a satisfying ending, at least for me. The female fans are the only worth to watch it, but this turns boring at some point.

2
Mixed Feelings