Reviews for Aikatsu Stars!

Before I started Aikatsu Stars (AiStars from now on), I was kind of worried. I’ve heard from multiple places that it ruined Aikatsu, that it turns to crap at a certain point of a show, stuff like that. Since I’ve heard those things about the 2nd season of Aikatsu and I ended up very much liking it*, I said, okay, how about watching it and finding it out yourself? It was indeed a disappointment, but in a positive way. In the end, it became my favorite show of all time second only to Ichigogen, also known as the first 2 seasons of the original Aikatsu(OGKatsu from here on). And after marathoning OGKatsu, especially after Akarigen, it felt refreshing.

Those who seek out the same kind of writing as in OGKatsu: you’re going to be disappointed. AiStars is a much more plot-driven show with a darker theme, even though it’s still a character-centric show at heart. If you outright hate drama or drama-centric episodes, this show is probably not for you. Friendly rivalries aren’t gone, but they’re much more serious, especially in the 2nd season; characters can be outright hostile to each other, with deep ideological differences. Idols no longer have to cater to each and every whim of the brand designers in order to acquire new dresses: they’re the brands themselves this time around, designing their own dresses. This goes hand in hand with the show’s main theme, self-producing. Special appeals, which were a big thing in OGKatsu, do exist, but they never get explained; this actually makes the story better, as it has other priorities. Yume is a much more expressive protagonist compared to Ichigo (or even Akari), not hiding her frustration, even capable of tantrums when things don’t go her way – she’s 12 years old after all. That doesn’t make either of them less of a great character (Ichigo is still one of my favorite characters of all time), just make either of these shows different. It has a much more modern feel to it: while OGKatsu felt like I’m watching a show from another decade (not that there’s anything wrong with it), AiStars has a much more dynamic feel to it, feeling very much like an anime from 2016. All in all, it ended up being its own thing without being unapologetic about it.

AiStars is not a perfect show, that’s not how I give out scores. Perfect shows simply don’t exist. It’s especially impossible for a show with 100 episodes. The CGI for the stage events is a stepback, for example. Characters who would’ve deserved to have their comeuppance ended up being redeemed without much of an explanation. Plot points ended up being abandoned and never much mentioned again (and don’t let your nostalgia goggles fool you: this was the same case in OGKatsu as well). Some side characters would’ve deserved their own stage events *cough*Haruka Luka*cough*

But there are plenty of other things making up for it. The characters are well-written and have complex motivations. You’ll end up caring for them, investing in them. The music is catchy as hell. The show is looking beautiful and as I’ve said earlier, dynamic. The voice acting is stellar, especially Yume’s – she’s voiced by Tomita Miyu, the same VA who voiced Riko in Made In Abyss; remember this name in the future.

If these things ended up convincing you, watch Aikatsu Stars. You’re not going to regret it.

*yeah, I’m a DreAca apologist, and I’m not sorry

PS: Koharu is best girl

After the amazing experience I had with the original Aikatsu, Stars had a big challenge to face trying to live up to its quality, did it succeed? Definitely! Aikatsu Stars keeps most of what makes the franchise shine with it's wholesomeness, heartwarming moments, and the constant pain in your mouth due to how much you're smiling watching it, but what this entry has is considerably more drama and serious moments through the story attached to the character development of the cast. If you prefer that this is a big bonus towards trying out Stars, while not really being a negative if you liked the original andyou're thinking about watching this one since in my opinion it was well handled through the whole run.

Outside of two fantastic crossover episodes with the original (which are perfectly skippable if you haven't watched it) this is a stand-alone story set in an idol school which focuses on “self-producing” (finding your way to stand out and shine, encouraging the search of what makes each of the students unique and great).

There are four classes, each specializing on different things, like singing and performing, with the best student of each becoming part of the S4 (best school uniforms in anime btw), the top members of the school that everyone admires and wants to become a part of. The protagonist of the story, Yume, is one of the tons of fans they have and she joins the school wishing to reach the top, will she succeed?

With the people behind Aikatsu having more experience with the franchise, there comes two quite strong positives in comparison to the original:

- The dances are great from episode 1. The CGI of the original at the start of its run was… mediocre to say the least, but at this point of the franchise things are way different. If you can't stomach the performances at the start of the first series, Aikatsu Stars (or the also awesome Aikatsu Friends) is there for you.

- The story is more compact and less repetitive: While the original has a ton of positives on what happens during the episodes, it's clear that they were just trying stuff at times and ditching them later on to do other things instead, or some parts were like doing 2-3 episodes in a row of the same thing but with different characters, Aikatsu Stars handles this way better and presents a well paced story while keeping the quality and the character development that the original shines with.

The strongest part of the Aikatsu franchise is its fantastic characters, and Stars is definitely not an exception to the rule. Before touching on the main characters, I will talk a bit more about the S4 girls, who are some of the best role model characters I have seen. They are at the top of the school and it's well deservedly so, being extremely good at what they do and always there to help the others to improve. They also get focus and development through the series, and the interactions between them and the main characters are some of the best moments of Stars. My own favorite character of this anime is the cheerful Yuzu, there are so many favorite-worthy characters even outside of the main ones!

Now let's talk a bit about the main characters:

- Yume Nijino is our protagonist of the story. She's a cheerful girl with strong determination and her talent for singing is incredible. You will see yourself cheering for her success and the smiles she wants to give to everyone.

- Rola/Laura Sakuraba she's Yume's rival (and therefore best friend by Aikatsu standards) and one of the strongest characters when it comes to their drama and development. She doesn't like losing at all, and in a world full of competition like hers this proves to be a problem.

- Ako Saotome, usually looking calm and confident, but actually quite hot-blooded, our (cat)girl loves acting and has a talent for it. She also has a massive crush on Subaru (a member of the M4, basically the S4 of the boys and source of lots of awesome interactions with the main cast) which leads to a lot of fun moments.

- Mahiru Kasumi, the most mature girl of the main cast. She shines at modeling, and while her strong aura makes her look difficult to approach (her karate skills don't help with that), she's actually pure kindness.

- Koharu Nanakura, a quiet girl and Yume's childhood friend. She joined the school together with her due to her admiration towards the S4, and they are always helping each other.

This is just a part of the whole cast and it's definitely missing other characters you will probably get to love as much or even more as them (looking at you Lily!)

As mentioned above, unlike the original, Stars has quality performances right from the start, that together with the great songs the series has makes for such a fantastic experience and a filled playlist. When it comes to the visuals, this anime is always on point, with some of the most important episodes delivering crazy good animation to add to the impact of the moment.

Keeping strengths from the original, presenting another fantastic cast, and giving us more awesome songs that will go to our playlists, Aikatsu Stars delivers a fantastic story full of both fun and emotional moments that, together with the solid character development, makes for a very memorable experience.

Thanks a lot for reading! I hope this review convinced you to at least put Aikatsu Stars in the endless void that is the plan to watch from your list, now that I'm up to date with this franchise I feel so empty, a feeling I wouldn't be surprised if you felt as well after watching it!

With the common motif in the anime being cliche, it also demonstrates it's own repetition. Many of the songs are reused numerous times, even in the same episode. The dress maker transformation seems to happen every episode as a filler. The predictability of the plot and the characters being your basic shoujo/idol main characters does not make me want to finish the series. This is your typical 'cute girl' anime while the live performance costumes ruin the 'cute.' I would not want to continue watching this anime to see if it gets better. In conclusion: if you watch oneSchool Idol anime, you have watched them all.

I have watched aikatsu since the first original one and the first season of aikatsu itself is really good in my opinion. Though, it become more 'weird' and having no clear direction of the story, after it ended, I have quite high hopes for aikatsu stars. Still, Aikatsu stars has some similarities with the original aikatsu which some makes me happy and some not. For the characters for instance, I don't know why but I kinda think that they are kind of running out of ideas in making new characters? because in my opinion, almost every main character are like fusion of two characters from the original one. LikeYozora, its really obvious that she's a fusion of Ran (appearance) and Sora (name partly and personality). Then Yuzu, fusion of Kii (appearance and most of the personality) and Aoi (some personalities). Hime is like some part Maria (surname and personality), Ichigo and Mizuki (both are like the adored senpai's). Ako is like Otome (appearance and surname) and Yurika (personality). Sakura has some Aoi vibe (both good at many things before) and added with Seira (rivalry). And as usual, Yume, the main idol is soemone who was not very good in idolhood like ichigo and akari.

It's kinda disturbing in my opinion though.

But, I love how they made few changes in the card system and the arts are actually pretty good.

What I love the most is the story is more.... intense, darker and romantic than the original one. I love how there's actually some mysteries about idols itself and its not just any plain boring mystery in my opinion. I also love the fact that it has some romance to it. It makes the story more interesting to watch, I think.

Story: 7 As with the original Aikatsu!, this series focused on idols, daily idol activities and competitions, which is typical in this franchise. For an anime aimed at kids, this was particularly well done, but I did notice that unlike in the original, this one had a slightly more mature tone that the original lacked, which made it enjoyable for the older audience. I won't say anything more to avoid spoiling but the drama in this was definitely heavier than its predecessor. Art: 10 The art is one of the strongest points in Stars!. Everything is so detail-focused that it's hard to say anything bad about the artat all. And I'm talking character and dress designs, and even backgrounds! The animation was also smooth and the 3D performances have definitely improved in quality since the original.

Sound: 10

Like the art, sound is one of the strongest points in this anime. No matter how many opening and ending songs there were, you remember each of them vividly as they were continually sung by the characters throughout the series at different times. Also, every single episode had a performance, so that was something to look forward to, especially if it was a new song. There was a multitude of songs in this, and that was typical for an anime about idols. Overall, the sound is just amazing.

Character: 8

Not much to say about the characters. They weren't poorly written but they weren't particularly special either. The characters' personalities are reminiscent of the original's, which is where everyone sports this positive attitude towards their activities most of the time. But unlike in the original, we actually get to see some antagonists pop up in the first and second half of Stars!. Elza Forte was especially memorable for her prominent role in the second half and I was surprised to see how that second half actually developed with her arrival in Japan. Other than that, the characters did their job of representing the themes of this anime well.

Enjoyment: 9

Despite my liking for action, horror, mystery and romance, this kind of genre puts me at ease and makes me excited at the same time. It's always refreshing to watch this anime, despite the repetitiveness. In other words, I enjoyed this, A LOT.

Overall: 8

Bringing everything together, Aikatsu Stars! is one spectacular anime to watch with kids and adults alike. I'd recommend this anime and this franchise in general, to people who are looking for something refreshing after a binge-watch session of Hellsing or other heavy anime, to get that balance back in place, especially if they don't mind this genre. Or just for anyone who's looking for a long anime to escape a bit of reality.

Story: 7/10 Great, just like all the other Aikatsu anime, they are all aiming to be top idols. Sometimes everything is repetitive, of course, to be expected since it's 100 episodes and it's an idol anime. Art:8/10 The art is kiddish, well it's an anime for children but regardless, I like the animation. Sound: 8/10 I like the music in this anime although it would be nice if they didn't dance to the same song for so long. Character: 5/10To be honest, they are kind of rip offs of the previous Aikatsus. Also, some characters are boring like Laura.

Enjoyment/Overall: 6/10

I don't think Aikatsu deserved a 100 episodes, however it was still good. It got much more exciting after around 70 episodes.

Of all the Aikatsu series so far, Stars is the most difficult to rank - partly because it doesn't seem to know what it's supposed to be. STORY: 5 The separation of classes creates an unequal skill balance between the many, many characters, and makes their competitive stories far less interesting, given tit makes the results of every audition even more predictable. Right from the start, it's clear that only one character can ever achieve their goals, and it's going to be the lead. At least in previous Aikatsu seasons, the lead wasn't always - in fact, rarely was - the winner. Then, there's the second season.Hoo boy. The ONE arc the fans unanimously hate - *cough* DreamAca *cough* - from the OG series, they basically went and repeated, only this time there was an active villain rather than a cast of competitors. More on that later.

Another major issue is the ridiculous amount of contradictions within the show's lore. I understand it was an attempt to make a system that stood out from it's predecessor, but instead, it's confusing, bizarre, and they regularly break their own so-called 'rules'.

CHARACTER: 5

What starts as Yume and Koharu - two best friends forever - following their dreams, soon becomes Yume and ... not Koharu? Maybe it's Rola/Laura? Honestly, I don't know any more. This show just kept throwing extra characters into the plot with no real sense of purpose - in fact, their characterizations are so generic and barely fleshed out, it's difficult to get attached to even the recurring and regular cast.

Only the most exaggerated and OTT characters are remotely memorable and original, but they get very annoying, very quickly - especially given their total lack of backstory to explain their weirdness.

Remember the evil villain character? She's got a whole 'evil plot to steal everything from everyone for selfish gains' thing going on. Only, she just sucks at it, and comes of as obnoxious rather than threatening or mysterious. In fact, her antics do nothing but distract our poor heroines from the actual plot! Aikatsu has always been about positive competition, but this addition in the second season tries- and fails - to throw that out the door.

They did, however, introduce full-time boy idols, and a boys-only Idol part of the school. I thought that was a great change, and brought about some interesting and dynamic relationships between various characters.

ART : 6.5

Aikatsu s1-2 had bad CGI. 3-4 was tolerable. And Stars? Well, they try darn hard on a relatively small budget. The dresses are gorgeous, the scenery is spectacular, and there's so many cool aesthetic moments. But the dancing scenes are nothing short of awkward, and the 2d movements are actually terrible, which is a shame.

SOUND : 7.5

It's Aikatsu, so the music is as great as you'd expect - there's so much variety, from pirate jives to gothic ballads to pop princess bops. And they're all really, honestly, fantastic to listen to! The OP and ED songs are all catchy and thematic. I just wish they'd had more team- and unit-based songs!

[SPOILER WARNING] I have seen everything. All of the original aikatsu episodes,the movie,ovas,specials etc.Now theres the newest aikatsu franchise which is aikatsu stars.As a huge aikatsu fan I of course loved this anime.It had everything I asked for cute girls,really nice 3D animated performances,and of course some cool fashion.As I write this I am on episode 49.I really love aikatsu and its such a fun,girly idol anime and I don't know if someone who is not into idol anime will enjoy this anime as much as i will. I feel like this as the first season was sorta flawed I feel like alot of more characters could've beenexplored more like all of S4.All i know is that they are superstars and not anything else.Also one of my favorite characters Koharu I wished had gotten more screen time but...

SPOILERS:she leaves yotsuboshi academy and 'goes to Italy' but thats not what it looks like in the 2nd season pv.

This first season is flawed and I only have great hopes that the 2nd season will finally get things

moving.Otherwise as a loyal aikatsu fan I really enjoyed this series and want more of it.If you

aren't into idol anime I suggest you won't enjoy this anime that much.Go watch the original

aikatsu and if that doesn't satisfy you then this series probably won't.

Before I start I'd like to just state as of this I've only seen S1 of Aikatsu Friends so I'm still pretty new into the franchise. Story Wise: 6.5 I may have given it a 7 in the but that's only because the rating system allows but I don't believe it deserves a 6. To be honest I'm very mixed on aspects of Aikatsu Stars. The first season 1-50 was really enjoyable as we got the growth of all the characters who were more than just background characters. I tend to classify characters in to 3 groups. Main, Main Supporting, and Sub Supporting. Subsupporting being characters that show up but don't have any major impact on the story. S2 though is where I take major issue the story and it faces demerits in my book. S2 story pushes an antagonist with some very clear issues and this detracts as a whole the further you go into s2.

Art: 8

It's more of a 7.5ish just because you can tell times when they cut corners to save for bigger moments within the ep/arc. Only other issue is certain contrasting design aspects in a couple crossover EP.

Character: 7.7

Main character and Main Supports do get a lot of attention as you would hope in a 100 ep series. My only real complaints is a certain character and then how they seem to be more than willing to do other characters dirty in my opinion. There were a good few ep I watched where I felt they dunked on characters for the sake of it.

Sound: 9 as a whole

One of the things a friend kept going on about in previous Aikatsu was how the songs were more varied than in Friends. I can agree and disagree. They largely used the same formula as what I saw in Friends but we have a more varied cast in Stars. Music as a whole was great though.

Enjoyment: 8.5 in reality but again MAL rating system only allows by whole point intervals.

S2 has some really solid moments but again is drug down by a character and to be honest initially those around her but they all get their own great moments.

Overall: 8

I said what I had in each section. Would I recommend this? Depends to be honest. It's a franchise technically aimed at little girls on top of being an idol anime on top of being 100 ep. If you already like ani-idol stuff I'd say yes go for it, if not it's honestly a hard sell.

Thank you for Aikatsu Stars! I enjoyed Aikatsu Stars very much! I love original Aikatsu so I watched this series. This series are somewhat inferior to original Aikatsu but it is pretty worth watching. Aikatsu series describe friendship well. Also this series do that well. I like Yume and Raula's friendship, Yuzu and Lilly's friendship, Yozora and Mahiru's family relationship. I like older S4 especially Yuzu and Yozora. Yuzu is quiet tolerant person and she is always worried about someone, she has warm heart. Yozora is always worried about her younger sister Mahiru. She is ideal sister, I think.I wonder Yozora failed against Mahiru on purpse or not??

Yozora tend to think that.

Anyway, all of older S4 are pretty wonderful people.

I wanted such person as my senior people.

I want to transfer to Yotsuboshi Academy XD

from now on, I am going to watch next season.

I'm looking forward to watch that too!!

Honestly, I had pretty middle of the road expectations. Previously I was watched a few episodes of Aikatsu friends when it debuted and it was very alright. It was honestly a surprise to be a lot more engage with it. With Stars, there's a focus given by the story and world building. There wasn't an episode where it felt force because the general plot help give the characters some focus, even if said episodes had nothing to do with the story. I really appreciate the constant theme of having the girls lose, being able to grieve for their failures before trying again, usually by changing theirgoals. It's hard to describe but it's really comforting to see.

Despite how very generic the first half looks conceptually, I think it's better than the second half. There's a lot of new elements in the second half that aren't really explained well as the first half, like why there's even a moon star coord (and how Hime even got it) when Elza and the other girls busted their ass for their star coords. Elza also seems unnaturally cold. Maybe I had a different perception of what her was but once her backstory was revealed it was like "oh..." She's understandably very cold and goal driven but she's never really criticized by people outside the main group. I also wish Rei had more of a goal outside of Elza.

The 3D segments takes some time getting used to, my real gripe with them is how wide the mouths can get. I'd say the songs in the later half are better than the first half but mostly since I remember and enjoy those more.